Private credit faces systemic 1929-style collapse
The bear case argued by guest Nick Nemeth is that the private credit market is a systemic bubble characterized by extreme leverage, opaque assets, and rising defaults that could trigger a broader financial crisis.
The argument
Nemeth argued that private equity firms are running excessive leverage at seven to nine times adjusted EBITDA, which relies on 'fake' earnings and unrealized synergies. He asserted that direct lending defaults are already above 2008 levels, and a prolonged period of high defaults will force downgrades of collateralized loan obligations (CLOs) held on insurance balance sheets.
The thesis, stress-tested
✓ What validates it
- ✓Direct lending default rates remaining above 6% for six consecutive quarters
- ✓Forced downgrades of CLO tranches held by major insurance companies
- ✓An increase in payment-in-kind (PIK) toggle usage among BDCs
▸ Risks discussed
- ▸Federal Reserve intervention or liquidity injections could temporarily freeze or rescue the credit markets
- ▸A sudden opening of the IPO window could allow private equity firms to exit investments and pay down debt
Hear it yourself
"But the smart money is a subprime this time Some of these private funds they not even including PIC in the leverage because it not cash and they don have which is payment in kind which is like i yeah i borrow you know a million dollars and i pay back 600 000 of it in cash i pay back 400 000 of it in payment in kind which means i just pay…"
00:00 / 00:59